Annie and Fannie are twins and the youngest of twelve siblings. They're in the little Amish school's Christmas play, which they must practice for regularly, but what they're really passionate about is horses. Oh, what they would give to have a horse of their own to ride and groom and care for. It's all they can think about. Well, that and the way their older sister Anna is swooning over Isaac, a sixteen-year-old boy who goes to the hymn singings on Sunday evenings. And the way their sister Esther can't stop talking about Noah, the nineteen-your-old boy who asked to drive her home in his horse and buggy. The twins have a hard time imagining being as boy crazy as their older sisters, but in an unexpected turn of events, they find themselves playing a crucial role in both sisters' relationships. Do they really want their beloved sisters to get married? Suddenly, they have a choice in the matter and must decide how they will wield their newfound power.